Showing posts with label Sieges and Fortifications. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sieges and Fortifications. Show all posts

Tuesday, 5 May 2026

"The Duke of Albany and Richard De la Pole are making preparations to go into Scotland", Richard de la Pole's proposed invasion of England, 1514


For the Bank Holiday weekend Charles Singleton from Helion, https://www.helion.co.uk/, invited Stuart, Martin Hughes, Simon Chick and myself for a wargame at Wightwick Manor. Whilst Stuart features regularly on the blog and covers his projects in fantastic detail at https://stuartsworkbench.blogspot.com/, Martin is a fellow 16th century wargame enthusiast and Simon runs Steelfist Miniatures, https://steelfistminiatures.com/, and of course has two superb blogs https://harness-and-array.blogspot.com/ and https://je-lay-emprins.blogspot.com/. Together all five of us used our combined terrain and miniature collections to put on an early 16th century spectacle.

Charles was keen that we did a game that focused on a "what if" scenario surrounding an invasion by the Yorkist claimant to the throne Richard de la Pole. De la Pole, also known as the "White Rose" because of his Yorkist credentials, has featured on the blog before. Back in 2018 Stuart and myself played a series of games based on an invasion by him, https://camisado1500s.blogspot.com/2018/05/the-last-white-rose.html, whilst I also played out a rerun of the 1487 Battle of Stoke, but this time setting it in 1514, with Jason, a friend from my re-enactment group. The 1514 version of the Battle of Stoke was based around de la Pole first landing in Ireland before then invading England and clashing with Henry VIII, https://camisado1500s.blogspot.com/2019/02/the-battle-of-stoke-field-1514_5.html.

As this is the third time a "what if" scenario featuring Richard de la Pole has been covered on the blog I thought it would be interesting to have a look at some of the evidence we have to suggest de la Pole was going to invade in 1514 before then going on to explain what the game was based on.

Richard de la Pole and the Duke of Albany's siege guns batter the walls of Berwick.

The French have brought over arms and armour to equip any Yorkist rebels that rally to de la Pole's cause.

"The French king this yere appoyneted to Richard dela Pole traitor of England and banished the realme. xii.M. lanceknyghtes"

Richard III's defeat at the Battle of Bosworth in August 1485 is perhaps one of the most famous events in English medieval history. Henry Tudor, a claimant to the English throne, backed by the French King Charles VIII, landed with a small force of English exiles and Scots and French mercenaries in Wales before successfully marching into England to defeat the last Plantagenet King of England and usher in the Tudor dynasty. Far less well known is the fact that the result of Bosworth could have potentially been reversed three decades later when a Yorkist claimant to the throne, Richard de la Pole, backed by Charles VIII's successor, Louis XII, nearly invaded England with a far more formidable force of 12,000 landsknecht.

Richard de la Pole was the son of John de La Pole, Duke of Suffolk, and, more importantly, Elizabeth of York, the sister of the Yorkist Kings Edward IV and Richard III. Richard's eldest brother John de la Pole, Earl of Lincoln had attempted to topple Henry Tudor, only two years after Bosworth in 1487 when he helped lead an invasion in support of the Yorkist pretender, Lambert Simnel. Purported to be Edward of Warwick, the son of the Duke of Clarence who was brother to the aforementioned Yorkist Kings Edward and Richard, Simnel had been crowned Edward VI in Dublin. The pretender's forces, comprising German and Irish mercenaries and some English rebels, were defeated at the Battle of Stoke where John de la Pole was slain.

Being in the line of succession to the English Crown had similarly dire consequences for two of Richard de la Pole's other brothers. Edmund de la Pole fled abroad in 1501 but was handed back to Henry in 1506 as a result of the English King's negotiations with Maximilian I whilst his brother William spent thirty seven years in the Tower of London due to his Yorkist ancestry. In 1513 Henry VIII had Edmund de la Pole executed which led Richard to assume the title of Duke of Suffolk. Unlike Edmund, who had remained within reach of Maximilian I whilst in exile, Richard had travelled to Buda and lived under the protection of the Hungarian King Vladislaus II.

By 1514 Richard de la Pole had already spent time in the service of the French. He took part in the 1512 Navarre campaign in command of a force of landsknecht and serving alongside the famous Chevalier Bayard where the two men became close friends. Jacques de Mailles, the author of Bayard's biography, recounted how
"The Duke of Suffolk was in this army, and had formed a very close friendship with our hero".
It is clear de la Pole was involved in heavy fighting as John Stile, the English Ambassador to Spain, wrote to Henry VIII in January 1513 stating: "yowr rebel Rychard De la Pole was yn the sayd warrys of Navar, cappytan of the Almaynys, where there yowr sayd rebel and hys cwmpany receveyd most hwrte and los of men then eny other of that party".
During 1513 Richard de la Pole remained in command of his landsknecht and may have fielded them against the English when Henry VIII invaded France in 1513 and captured the towns of Thérouanne and Tournai.

The Anglo-French war dragged on into 1514 and it was during this time that the invasion of England by de la Pole seems to have been proposed. Edward Hall wrote of 1514 in his chronicle that: 
"The French king this yere appoyneted to Richard dela Pole traitor of England and banished the realme. xii.M. lanceknyghtes to kepe Normandie, and also to entre into England and to conquere thesame, where they made suche a Ryott that many of them were slayn & he was fayn to carye them to sente Malos in Britaigne to take shippe: for the Frenchmen woulde fayne haue bene rydde of them they cared not how, there conditions were so vyle and shameful, but by the reason that the French kyng suyd tor peace, this jornay toke no effect".

It looks as though the plan was for de la Pole to lead a force of 12,000 landsknecht to garrison Normandy from where they would then continue to the Breton port of St Malo to embark for the invasion of England. Only the fact the Louis XII of France and Henry VIII of England made peace prevented this invasion from taking place.

That England was to be the initial landing point seems unlikely. Thirty four years later a French army would muster at Le Pellerin, located on the Loire River near Nantes, before taking ship to land at Leith in Scotland in June 1548. In June 1514 the English solider and official Sir Thomas Lovell wrote from France to bishops Wolsey and Foxe "The Duke of Albany and Richard De la Pole are making preparations to go into Scotland". Henry Tudor had of course landed in Wales in 1485 whilst Lambert Simnel's invasion had been launched from Ireland so it makes perfect sense that de la Pole may have intended to land in Scotland before crossing the border into England. Hall's Chronicle recounts how in 1523 "the duke of Albany sailed out of Scotland into France, & the French king somuch favered him, that as it was shewed to the kyng of England for trueth, that when the Frenche king rode through Paris he rode on the one hand & Richard de la Pole a traitor to England & by parliament attainted on the other hand, & that the duke had asked of the French kyng v.M. horsemen &. x.M Alamaines (Landsknecht), & that he had promised the French kyng if he had those xv.M. men, he would do one of these. iii. thynges, either sley the kyng of England in battail, or els take him prisoner, or els drive him out of his realme. These were shamefull bragges of a noble man and very folishe". Whilst not quite the 15,000 men claimed by Hall the Duke of Albany would lead around 3,000 French against Wark castle later in 1523 whilst at the same time the Earl of Surrey wrote to Wolsey how the Duke of Albany "doth make grete boost off the londyng off Ricard de la Pole in Scotlond assewryng the Lords off Scotland that he shall have gret help in this realm"

John Stewart, Duke of Albany, was a grandson of the Scots King James II, having been born in France to a French mother, Anne de la Tour d'Auvergne. His royal blood made Albany an important figure in Scottish politics. The commanders of the Scots fleet, the Earl of Arran and Lord Fleming, had been in France towards the end of 1513 and as such had not been present at Flodden when the Scots King James IV was killed. They were keen for Albany to return with them to Scotland to continue a war which they felt had been undertaken for French interests in support of the "auld alliance". 

The English also seemed to fear this with the town of Berwick, lying at the north-eastern corner of England on the Anglo-Scots border, being particularly at risk. On 10 March 1514 Henry VIII wrote to Lord Thomas Darcy, the Captain of Berwick, stating he "learns the news of the preparation made by the Scots against Berwick, and the desire of the town for aid. It shall be sent instantly". Henry then proceeded to berate Darcy over the reported state of the defences and defenders of Berwick. Ten days later Darcy wrote back to the king defending himself over the accusations of negligence in the defence and saying "On Friday, 10th March, the Scotch burnt five towns in the East Marches. On Saturday they came within two miles of Berwick, and at night removed up the Tweed and lay forgainst Foorthes, ready to cross into England....The Scots are ready to lay siege to Berwick, and only wait for Albany's coming with the French and the Danes, as he has written before". The Danes are mentioned as they too were part of the "auld alliance" at the time and it seems the Scots hoped for aid from them, especially as the Earl of Arran had supported them with a Scots naval expedition in 1502.

Luckily for Henry VIII and Lord Thomas Darcy the expected attack of 1514 never came. Albany did not arrive in Scotland to assume his role as regent until May 1515. Henry VIII and Louis XII made peace in August 1514, the peace deal being sweetened for Louis XII by his betrothal to Henry's 18 year old sister Mary. Being caught out in the cold by this diplomacy Richard de la Pole was sent to the free Imperial city of Metz with the Milanese Envoy, Marino Caracciolo, writing to the Duke of Milan on 17 August 1514 "A duke who has claims upon England and has served the King of France as a captain of lanzknechts will be dismissed".

Richard de la Pole's army outside the walls of Berwick. The army comprises a core of de la Pole's 12,000 landsknecht supported by some of Albany's French troops and Alexander Gordon, the Earl of Huntly's Scots.

"The Scots are ready to lay siege to Berwick, and only wait for Albany's coming with the French" 

So with the real events laid out what would have happened if Richard de la Pole with his 12,000 landsknecht had taken ship at St Malo in the summer of 1514 and landed at Leith accompanied by the Duke of Albany and a small French retinue? From the above it seems that an attack on Berwick could have been a possibility. Having changed hands numerous times from the twelfth to fifteenth centuries it was taken by Richard Duke of Gloucester (later to be Richard III) in 1482 and the Scots were keen to take it back as a matter of pride. 

Besieging Berwick in 1514 would mean the Franco-Scots force could slip back to safety across the border if need be but it would also have the possible advantage of drawing potential rebels with Yorkist sympathies to de la Poles banner and perhaps even drawing Henry VIII himself to the north so de la Pole could, in Hall's words "either sley the kyng of England in battail, or els take him prisoner, or els drive him out of his realme". If de la Pole could defeat Henry in pitched battle he may even be able to take the crown as Henry's father had himself done in August 1485.

Our scenario focuses on exactly this, an invasion by Richard de la Pole, the Duke of Albany and a large force the core of which are de la Pole's 12,000 landsknecht. The landsknecht are accompanied by Albany's additional French troops whilst Albany's supporter, and survivor of Flodden, Alexander Gordon, Earl of Huntly has also rallied to his banner.

As Lord Thomas Darcy, the Captain of Berwick, and the vice-captain Sir Anthony Ughtred, attempt to hold the town against the French and Scots guns an enraged Henry VIII has quickly raised an army and headed north with his close friend and newly created Duke of Suffolk, Charles Brandon, in command of the vanguard. The Duke of Suffolk of course being the same title assumed by de la Pole. The game focuses on Henry's arrival at the siege lines where the Franco-Scots forces have turned to face him. As the battle begins Darcy and Ughtred lead a sally out into the siege lines.

Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, arrives outside the walls of Berwick with the English cavalry vanguard...

...whilst King Henry arrives with a core of loyal troops and some local borderers who have been mustered to defend England's northern border. It looks as though the Royal forces are heavily outnumbered!

Scenario

The game was played using our modified Renaissance Rampant, Lion Rampant Rules. Each army was formed of three retinues. The Franco-Scots army comprised Richard de la Pole in command of his landsknecht, Albany in command of a force of French and Scots and Alexander Gordon, Earl of Huntly, in command of more Scots. The relieving army comprised the vanguard under Charles Brandon and the mainward under Henry VIII whilst Lord Thomas Darcy would lead the garrison of Berwick.

The game started with Henry VIII and Suffolk facing Richard de la Pole, Albany and Huntly in the siege lines around Berwick. During the game Thomas Darcy would lead a sally from the walls of Berwick (see the rules below).

We had quite a few extra rules for this scenario focusing on potential treachery in Henry's ranks, the presence of the Bastard Heron in the English army and the use of the guns from both the walls of Berwick and the Franco-Scots camp to aid in the battle. In all the discussion and chaos of the day I managed to forget to include all of these once the game was underway!

Turn sequence

To further add to the confusion the order in which the retinues acted changed each turn. Each retinue, the three English  and three Franco-Scots, had a coloured dice. At the start of the game 5 dice were placed in a bag. Each turn a dice was taken from the bag and the retinue whose dice was drawn would then act. As soon as the fist melee took place the dice for the Berwick Garrison was also added to the bag. This was done for all retinues every turn. If a retinue was wiped out its dice was removed from the bag.

The sally from the walls of Berwick

The Berwick garrison did not start on the table. As soon as the first melee was fought the following turn the garrison could emerge from the gates via normal activations. The garrison could emerge via a move or attack activation, they could not emerge via a shooting activation.

Victory

The victory conditions were simple. Each side had three retinue leaders. As soon as one side had two of the retinue leaders killed or routed the other side won. If this happened on the same turn then the game was considered a draw.

From the walls of Berwick the huge Scots, landsknecht and French army prepares for battle.

The Franco-Scots army is short on cavalry as the French have arrived by ship and the Scots can provide only a small number of border horse.

Richard de la Pole, the "White Rose", is surrounded by his landsknecht but has also managed to rally a small number of English rebels to his cause.

A view of the table from above. The walls of Berwick can be seen to the right of the photo. The garrison under the command of Lord Thomas Darcy will sally from the gatehouse during the battle. Top right is John Stewart, Duke of Albany's retinue of French, Scots and landsknecht. Top middle is Alexander Gordon, Earl of Huntly's retinue of Scots and top left is the landsknecht retinue of Richard de la Pole with a few Yorkist rebels. Bottom left of the photo is the English vanguard under Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk whilst bottom centre is Henry VIII and the English mainward. At present it looks as if the English have miscalculated in their attack and are heavily outnumbered!

The Armies

For the game Stuart and Martin took command of Richard de la Pole's invasion force whilst Simon and I took command of the Tudor army. Charles took on the role of host overseeing the action and providing the tiring commanders with excellent refreshments during the heat of battle!

The English army of Henry VIII

Henry VIII and the English mainward

1 Unit of Yeoman of the Guard with arquebus (unit includes Henry VIII, King of England, retinue leader)
2 Units of Retinue Bill
2 Units of Retinue Archers
1 Unit of Border Foot
1 Culverin

Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk and the English vanguard

1 Unit of Kings Spears (unit includes Charles Brandon, Duke of Suffolk, retinue leader)
2 Units of Demilancers 
1 Unit of Mounted Archers
2 Units of Border Horse

Lord Thomas Darcy and the garrison of Berwick

1 Unit of Foot Knights (unit contains Lord Thomas Darcy, Captain of Berwick, retinue leader)
1 Unit of Foot Knights (unit contains Sir Anthony Ughtred, Vice-captain of Berwick)
3 Units of Shire Bill
2 Units of Shire Archers

Richard de la Pole's landsknecht and John Stewart, Duke of Albany's French and Scots

Richard de la Pole, "Duke of Suffolk" and the "White Rose"

1 Unit of Foot Knights (unit contains Richard de la Pole, "Duke of Suffolk", retinue leader)
4 Units of Landsknecht Pike
1 Unit of Landsknecht Arquebusiers
1 Unit of Landsknecht Halberdiers
1 Unit of Shire Archers (Yorkist Rebels)
1 Unit of Shire Bill (Yorkist Rebels)
1 Culverin

John Stewart, Duke of Albany

1 Unit of Gendarmes (unit contains John Stewart, Duke of Albany, retinue leader) 
1 Unit of French men at arms
1 Unit of Landsknecht
2 Units of Aventuriers
1 Unit of French Pike
2 Units of Lowland Pike

Alexander Gordon, Earl of Huntly

1 Unit of Foot Knights (unit contains Alexander Gordon, Earl of Huntly, retinue leader)
2 Units of Lowland Pike
1 Unit of Scots Arquebusiers
1 Unit of Border Horse
2 Units of Highlanders

With five of us involved and large numbers of troops on the field as you can probably imagine there was a lot going on in this game. The captions under the photos capture some of the action but a very brief summary of what went on also follows.

Henry VIII, surrounded by his yeoman of the guard and household troops, surveys the traitor's host that opposes him.

The fighting begins with English border horse launching skirmishing attacks on de la Pole's landsknecht whilst the English archers advance to prepare to shoot at the enemy force.

Some of Albany's French troops advance to fire upon the English.

A view of the field as the opposing forces skirmish and shoot at one another.

Brandon and the mounted English vanguard are preparing to attack de la Pole's landsknecht.

English levies raised on the border shoot at the highlanders from Huntly's Scottish contingent.

As the English archers send a storm of arrows into the Franco-Scottish army Henry orders his artillery to open fire. 

Some of the English rebels, Yorkist diehards who have joined de la Pole's army, take casualties as the English border horse attack.

Albany has brought a small cavalry contingent over from France and they lead his advance past the gates of Berwick.

The landsknecht arquebusiers under de la Pole's command fire back at the border horse who have been making skirmishing attacks against them.

French arquebusiers and English archers exchange shots at each other.

Some of Brandon's demilancers charge into the highlanders and drive them back...

...whilst more highlanders charge Henry's archers and fierce fighting takes place.

As Charles Brandon arrived on the field with the mounted English vanguard he was horrified to find a vast army arrayed beneath the walls of Berwick. Brandon had been informed that Richard de la Pole, the traitor who was using the same title as Brandon, the Duke of Suffolk, had brought over thousands of landsknecht and a small contingent of French but had not realised quite how many Scots had also crossed the border, keen to avenge the death of their King, James IV, the previous autumn at Flodden. Had this information been deliberately kept from the Royal army in an attempt to lure Brandon and his king, Henry, into a trap?

The English King, Henry VIII, then took the field with his artillery and the mainward, made up of Henry's best household troops with a seasoning of local border levies who had been quickly raised to defend the northern border. Brandon's cavalry were first to move as the border horse in the English vanguard made skirmishing attacks on de la Pole's landsknecht. At the same time Henry's archers advanced and sent a shower of arrows into the Franco-Scots army which responded by sending forward its own arquebusiers to fire back supported by highland archers and a small force of English archers who had joined de la Pole.

These firefights and skirmishes soon led to melees breaking out. Brandon's demilancers charged down a force of Gordon highlanders whilst a second group of highlanders made repeated attacks on the English army's centre. The gaelic charge brought the highlanders dangerously close to Henry but they were driven back by Henry's archers and guns.

The Earl of Huntly's Gordon forces advance on the English king's position.

A group of French pikemen, brought over by John Stewart, Duke of Albany, prepare to advance.

The fight sways back and forth in the centre of the field...

...with the attacks by the highlanders getting dangerously close to Henry and his yeoman of the guard.

The gates of Berwick suddenly swing open and billmen from the garrison charge into Albany's Scottish troops...

...a bloody melee takes place...

...and Albany's French men at arms charge into the fray.

Determined to lead from the front the Captain of Berwick, Lord Thomas Darcy, charges into the French men at arms only by to caught by lance thrust and instantly slain!

Determined to avenge his captain Sir Anthony Ughtred, vice-captain of Berwick, also joins the fight. Ughtred has more success and succeeds in driving Albany's men back.

Sir Anthony Ughtred and the Duke of Albany's bodyguard of gendarmes exchange blows.

More of the garrison of Berwick, supported by armed citizens from the town, charge out of the gates into the fighting.

As skirmishes and melees took place beyond the siege lines the gates of Berwick suddenly flung open and the Captain of Berwick, Lord Thomas Darcy, led his men in a sally from the town walls. John Stewart, the Duke of Albany's troops were closest to the walls and took the full force of the garrison's attack. A handful of French men at arms had made the sea crossing with Albany and were now to play a key role in the battle. Seeing Darcy emerging from the walls, the men at arms, who had ridden past the gates of Berwick, turned and charged. Lord Thomas Darcy took a direct hit from a French lance and was killed. The English forces had now lost one of their commanders.

Despite the death of their captain the garrison of Berwick did not retreat back into the town. Instead command fell to the vice-captain, Sir Anthony Ughtred, who led a renewed assault on the French and Scots troops outside the gatehouse. The fighting was particularly bloody, with both sides taking heavy casualties, but it did not take long for the sallying garrison to gain the upper hand. Ughtred's men unhorsed Albany in the chaotic fight and seeing this the rest of Albany's troops fled or withdrew.

At the other end of the field de la Pole's troops are still being held back by Brandon's outnumbered cavalry forces.

The heaviest fighting has taken place outside the gates of Berwick. In the chaos John Stewart, the Duke of Albany, is unhorsed whilst fighting Sir Anthony Ughtred's men. Both the English and Franco-Scottish armies have now lost a commander.

At the other end of the field Brandon's demilancers drive back a force of English rebels.

Albany's forces begin to withdraw from the gates of Berwick.

In the centre of the field Huntly's Scottish contingent continue to advance on Henry's position...

...but the smaller English contingent contains Henry's household troops and they rain shot and arrows into the attacking Scots.

English borderers clash with Scots borderers...

...whilst more Scots attempt to force their way across the bridge.

A priest briefly tries to quell the bloodshed...

...but the fighting continues with the Scots being unable to successfully storm Henry's position.

As the fighting subsided around the gatehouse the Scots under the command of Huntly and the landsknecht under de la Pole pushed forward towards the Tudor king in an attempt to overwhelm the English forces. Although the English were heavily outnumbered Sir Charles Brandon's demilancers and border horse continued to attack the advancing landsknecht whilst the English infantry and guns positioned around Henry ensured that as the Scots and landsknecht advanced they were repeatedly driven back.

Fierce melees took place as Scots and landsknecht pikemen attempted to reach Henry. De la Pole's mercenaries suffered terribly as they were lured towards the English light guns which unleashed a hail of grapeshot into the closely packed ranks of landsknecht, slaughtering many of them. As the Franco-Scots attack began to falter Sir William Brandon saw an opportunity to charge the Earl of Huntly. At the head of the King's Spears Brandon thundered into Huntly and his personal bodyguard and in a one on one duel the Scots nobleman was slain. With his two allies, Albany and Huntly, out of the battle de la Pole quickly slipped back into Scotland. 

It had been a bloody engagement. Berwick had been relieved but much to Henry's fury the final Yorkist claimant to the English throne remained at large. He may have saved his position as king but Henry knew he couldn't rest easily until de la Pole was eliminated.

As de la Pole's landsknecht advance on Henry his guns open fire at very close range sending murderous grapeshot into the densely packed ranks of landsknecht. The attack has faltered.

As the Franco-Scottish attack stalls Brandon sends his Kings Spears into the field and is able to seek out the Earl of Huntly. The two men engage in a brief duel in which Huntly is slain. With his two main commanders gone Richard de la Pole calls a retreat and his army abandons it's camp and siege lines slipping back into Scotland. De la Poles invasion has been stopped but the traitor still lives!

This game was quite the spectacle and a lot of fun to play through. It was a joy to see everyone's figures and pieces of terrain on the table and great to meet Martin, Charles and Simon. Charles was a fantastic host and of course there was plenty of chat about the hobby and history. We thought it only fitting to take a suitably ridiculous group photo before having a few post battle wines and beers!

A picture of the Captains and the Tudor standard!

Sunday, 1 February 2026

"the infidels suffered a defeat of such magnitude that it cannot even be described", the Siege of Žrnov, April-May 1515


Last weekend one of my re-enactment friends, Phil, joined me for an off season catch up and a wargame. We thought it would be fun to refight a clash that took place just south of Belgrade in 1515. Much of what we know about the clash that took place outside Žrnov is taken from a letter written by Prince Suleiman, before he was Sultan, and can be found in the appendix to this article about one of the battles protagonists, Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, https://www.academia.edu/40391429/Wolf_on_the_Border_Yahyapa%C5%9Fao%C4%9Flu_Bali_Bey_1527_. I would recommend giving it a read as it really helps to capture the flavour of this period and the clashes that took place along the border between the Kingdom of Hungary and the Ottoman Empire.

We wanted the game to look like a big battle yet not take all day so the scenario we played did not have many units but we used lots of figures to represent each unit. This gave a suitably large scale look but meant we could finish our game in under three hours. As you will see things did not go the way of the historical battle!

"They shot it with their cannons from several places and opened gaps". The walls of Žrnov have been battered by the Hungarian artillery.

 "the depraved infidels marched against the fortress called Havale and surrounded it". The Hungarian camp before the walls of Žrnov known to the Ottomans as Havale.

The Ottoman garrison of Žrnov look out from the walls of the fortress hoping to see the arrival of a relief army.

The Siege of Žrnov, April-May 1515

The location of Serbia's "Monument to the Unknown Hero" on the top of the Avala Mountain, lying to the south of Belgrade, was once the site of the medieval fortress of Žrnov. It first fell to the Ottomans in 1442 but having been returned to the Serbs following the Peace of Szeged, in 1444, it was then recaptured in 1458. Being so close to Belgrade the Ottomans had used the fort as a counter to the city and it had become a stronghold from which they could disrupt communications with Šabac, which lay downstream from Belgrade on the Sava river.

Following the Hungarian defeat at the battle of Mohacs in 1526 John Zápolya would become a contender to the Hungarian throne (see https://camisado1500s.blogspot.com/2021/08/tarcal-1527.html and https://camisado1500s.blogspot.com/2024/02/szina-1528.html) but prior to this he was key to the defence of Hungary's contested border with the Ottomans. Zápolya was made voevode of Transylvania by the Hungarian King, Vladislaus, in November 1510. It was in this role with the aid of some of the local nobility and bans, these being the military governors of the Hungarian Kingdom's outlying territories, that Zápolya led an army to besiege Žrnov in the spring of 1515. In his excellent "From Nicopolis to Mohács: A History of Ottoman-Hungarian Warfare, 1389-1526", Tamás Pálosfalvi states "At the end of April the voevode, István Bátori, the bans of Belgrade (Imre Török and Mihály Paksi), that of Šabac (Gáspár Paksi), and some of the southern lords such as the Jakšić and the Szakolyi entered Ottoman territory “with a good number of troops,” and laid siege to the castle of Žrnov"

It seems Zápolya thought that the regional Ottoman forces were engaged in a campaign in Bosnia, indeed some of them had launched an attack to the south west which would result in the Ottomans occupying the castles of Bočac and Kotor in May 1515, and because of this he paid little regard to the idea that they would attempt to relieve Žrnov. Zápolya and his army were thus caught by surprise when the Ottoman Sanjakbey of Semendire, Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, led an army drawn from troops in Rumelia to relieve the fortress. Zápolya and his forces bombarded the walls of Žrnov and the defenders of the fortress feared it would fall to an assault. In a letter that no lesser a figure than Suleiman the Magnificent himself, at the time Prince Suleiman as he was not yet Sultan, wrote to the pashas of the imperial council based on Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey’s reports Suleiman stated (translated to English):

"The sancakbeyis were just about to have the sipahi and akıncı troops march to Semendire when the depraved infidels marched against the fortress called Havale (Žrnov) and surrounded it. They shot it with their cannons from several places and opened gaps. Before the other sancakbeyis could join Bali Bey, the servants of your eminences, sancakbeyis Mesih of Vidin, Ahmed of Alacahisar, Kasım of Prizren and Hacı of İzvornik arrived there and held a council. They planned to await the other beys and together they would take up the fight against the infidels. However, the defenders of Havale then sent a messenger down from the aforenamed fortress and informed the beys that if they did not arrive there by the next day, then – since they had no more men and they had no strength to fight – an assault would be launched against the fortress."

With no time to spare Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey could not await the arrival of further reinforcements and so an assault was made on the Hungarian siege lines. The Ottoman infantry attacked the Hungarian infantry and siege guns whilst the Sanjakbey's cavalry attacked the Hungarian cavalry who counter charged out of the Hungarian camp. Prince Suleiman's report describes the action, although I think we can take the "20,000 armored cavalry" from the Hungarian camp as an exaggeration: 

"The sancakbeyis, the servants of your eminences, disregarding the dearth of people of Islam and the multitude of infidels and asking incessantly for divine mercy and for the help of the holy spirit of his holiness the prophet – may his name be glorified! – and knowing that the exalted support and superior power of the padishah, the refuge of the world, were with them, placed alongside the close relatives of the aforenamed Bali Bey, the servants of your eminences, the ziamet-holder Bali and Rüstem, the azab ağası and beşlü ağası and in addition the most valiant and brave soldiers of Semendire, who as infantrymen attacked the foot soldiers standing alongside the cannons of the infidels positioned below the fortress and dispersed them. The sancakbeyis arrived in their tracks and assailed the camp of the infidels. As they began to fight, around 20,000 armoured cavalry rushed out from the camp of the infidels and an enormous battle took place from morning until afternoon. The infidel cavalry could not hold out, again withdrew to the camp and for a while fought from there. Finally, the multitude of flags bearing the sign of divine assistance and the deterrent spectacle of the heroes who enjoyed the abundant and miraculous support of the saints threw fear into the cavalry and the infantry of the infidels and unable to resist the effort of the fighters for the faith, they surrendered their camp."

Prince Suleiman's report continues to describe how the defeated Hungarians were chased back to Belgrade with many being killed, becoming "the food of the steely, shining sword" whilst others were captured and imprisoned. The brothers Mihály and Gáspár Paksi, being the bans of Belgrade and Szabács, were both killed whilst 600-700 wagons and all the Hungarian artillery and siege equipment was captured. Zápolya, who Suleiman describes as "The accursed known as the ban of Transylvania" managed to escape the disaster:

"Then through the mercy and support of God in the prosperous days of his majesty the sovereign, the army of the infidels scattered and much of it became the food of the steely, shining sword, while those infidels who escaped the saber were placed in shackles and locked in the fortress. The infidels left behind 600–700 camp wagons, all of their shields, cannons, flags, and tents as well as their other military equipment and instruments and, defeated and hopeless, took to their heels. Our fighters for the faith raised the flag of victorious Islam and assailed the infidels all the way until Belgrade, taking the heads of the ban of Belgrade Mihály Paksi and the ban of Szabács. The accursed known as the ban of Transylvania managed to escape with a few thousand infidels and gathering all his strength fled to the fortress of Belgrade. During the prosperous time of his majesty the padishah –the shadow of Allah on earth – the infidels suffered a defeat of such magnitude that it cannot even be described."

Once Belgrade fell to the Ottomans in 1521 (https://camisado1500s.blogspot.com/2024/08/the-siege-of-belgrade-1521.html) Žrnov would loose its strategic importance. Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey and his akinji would play a key role in the Battle of Mohacs in 1526, whilst John Zápolya, who did not fight at Mohacs, would become king of eastern Hungary after his clashes with Ferdinand of Hapsburg following that same fateful Hungarian defeat in 1526.

A view of the table with the walls of Žrnov at the top and the camp of John Zápolya on the left with his army deployed in front. On the right is the Rumelian army of Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey.

A view of the Hungarian army deployed below the siege guns.

John Zápolya hastily leads the Hungarian army out the camp to the face the Ottoman threat.

Scenario

Phil is much more a re-enactor and fan of late medieval history than a wargamer so the game was played out as a straightforward battle with victory going to the first player to halve the opponents army. If this happened to both players on the same turn then the game would be a draw.

We used a modified version of Lion Rampant for the rules but with much bigger units as described above. Although the figure count was higher each cavalry unit still counted as 6 figures and each infantry unit as 12 figures. The battle took place in front of the Hungarian camp and siege lines. Following the description of events in Prince Suleiman's letter each player had to deploy their infantry forces opposing one another beneath the Hungarian guns and the cavalry forces in front of the Hungarian Camp facing one another.

The Armies

John Zápolya, voevode of Transylvania, and the Hungarian besieging army

1 Unit of Gendarmes (Includes retinue leader John Zápolya, voevode of Transylvania)
1 Unit of Men at Arms (Under command of István Bátori, Count of Temesvár)
2 Units of Hussars
1 Unit of Balkan Cavalry
1 Unit of Pavise Infantry with crossbows
2 Units of Pavise Infantry with arquebuses

Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, Sanjakbey of Semendire, and the Ottoman relief army

1 Unit of Delis (Includes retinue leader Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, Sanjakbey of Semendire)
3 Units of Sipahis
3 Units of Akinji
1 Unit of Voynuks
1 Unit of Azab Infantry
1 Unit of Azab Archers

This was a fairly quick game so there are as many photos of the initial set up as of the battle itself! As always the captions below the photos are a good way to follow the action and a brief write up of events also follows.

John Zápolya, the "accursed known as the ban of Transylvania" and his gendarmes take up position behind the hussars.

Another unit of hussars emerges from the camp.

István Bátori (Stephen VII Báthory) prepares his men at arms.

The Ottoman akinji and sipahis arrive in front of the Hungarian camp.

"The sancakbeyis arrived in their tracks and assailed the camp of the infidels."

The two forces face each other below the walls of Žrnov.

Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, Sanjakbey of Semendire, takes up position behind the Rumelian sipahis and voynuk infantry.

The Ottoman infantry and cavalry prepare to attack.

Bali Bey's army moves first, charging the Hungarians.

István Bátori, Count of Temesvár, leads a thunderous charge into the akinji on the Ottoman left flank and scatters them.

At Zápolya's command the Hungarians begin to push forward.

"As they began to fight, around 20,000 armoured cavalry rushed out from the camp of the infidels and an enormous battle took place from morning until afternoon."

A wall of Hungarian infantry advances. They are well protected from the Ottoman arrows by their pavises.

To the sound of booming drums the Rumelian army of the Sanjakbey of Semendire, Yahyapaşaoğlu Bali Bey, emerged before the walls of the beleaguered fortress of Žrnov. The alarm sounded in the Hungarian camp and John Zápolya's army quickly prepared for battle as it became clear that the camp was under attack. Some of the akinji of Bali Bey's army rode forward trying to draw the Hungarian cavalry from out of their fortified camp so they could be defeated in the open. Initially the akinji succeeded and a unit of hussars were drawn out and quickly defeated. Eager to avenge their countrymen the men at arms under István Bátori, Count of Temesvár, then gave chase. The speed of the men at arms took the akinji by surprise and they were caught by the armoured cavalry as they attempted to evade them. István Bátori's men rode straight through the foremost unit of akinji, sending them in flight from the battlefield.

István Bátori and his men were now surrounded by Ottoman cavalry and it looked as if they would be quickly overwhelmed. Under Bátori's wolf’s teeth and dragon banner his men at arms held firm and took the fight to the centre of Bali Bey's left flank. In the series of fierce cavalry melees that followed some of Bátori's men fell but they succeeded in driving all of Bali Beys akinji from the field. The left flank of the Ottoman army had been broken by the heroic charge of one unit of men at arms!

Bali Bey's forces continue to advance.

The skirmishing attacks of the akinji have broken one of the units of hussars. To avenge them István Bátori charges into the attacking akinji...

...who fail to evade him and are defeated. Bátori's cavalry then crash into yet more akinji causing chaos on the Ottoman left flank.

Bali Bey's left flank crumbles as István Bátori's men at arms charge into the Ottoman lines. 

Closer to the castle walls the voynuks are subjected to a rain of bolts from the Hungarian infantry. The morale of the voynuks fails and they flee the battlefield.

The rest of the Ottoman infantry then face a hail of shot and bolts from the Hungarian lines.

Zápolya's infantry push forward as the Ottomans start to be driven back.

István Bátori and his men regroup having defeated three units of akinji.

Whilst a vicious cavalry battle raged on the Ottoman left flank the Hungarians advanced on Bali Bey's infantry on the Ottoman right. Under the cover of their pavises the Hungarian infantry, protecting their gun battery which continued to bombard the walls of Žrnov, advanced to within range of the voynuks and azabs who faced them. Coming under a withering rain of crossbow bolts the heavily armoured voynuks advanced on Zápolya's infantry confident that they could reach them and drive them from the field. 

As the voynuks advanced they suffered more casualties despite their armour. The voynuks nerve failed and they fled. At the same time, having initially had some morale issues themselves, the Hungarian arquebusiers advanced to within range of the azabs and opened fire. The azabs fell back attempting to avoid the hail of shot but this only encouraged the Hungarians to advance. The azabs were driven from the field and the Ottoman right flank collapsed. In the centre of the Ottoman lines Bali Bey, surrounded by his sipahis and delis realised all was lost. His troops were still fresh but so was the Hungarian centre. John 
Zápolya, the "accursed known as the ban of Transylvania", and his gendarmes had yet to even leave the cover of their camp. The relief of Žrnov had failed and Bali Bey withdrew, leaving the garrison to it fate. 

Thanks to the heroic charge of István Bátori the Hungarian army did not become "the food of the steely, shining sword" and did not suffer "a defeat of such magnitude that it cannot even be described"!

Things are not looking good for Bali Bey and his Rumelian army!

The Ottoman infantry continue to be driven back by bolts and shot from the Hungarian infantry...

...and the whole of the Ottoman attack has been stalled.

Having lost too many of his men in the attack Bali Bey breaks off his attempt to relieve Žrnov. He abandon's the field leaving the garrison of Žrnov to their fate.

This game made for a fun morning and, much to Phil's amusement, a total defeat for my Ottomans! Phil lost one unit of men at arms whilst all my akinji and my best infantry were quickly sent fleeing from the field. My plan had been to avoid the Hungarian infantry and draw the Hungarian cavalry out into a fight where my skirmishers and sipahis, all armed with bows, would be able to defeat them. I did not count on István Bátori's men at arms charging in and completely destroying my left flank as my akinji kept failing to evade! Phil was also quick to realise that he could advance the Hungarian infantry and slowly degrade my opposing infantry with his crossbowmen and arquebusiers.

We felt the plan to use big units but a low unit count to fight a quicker game worked really well. The table looked suitably dramatic whilst the game was manageable although had my army not crumbled so quickly it could have gone on for a bit longer. Of course Phil and I felt we had to bring a touch of re-enactment to the wargame and as Phil has a pavise and crossbow we couldn't refight this battle without a photo of the "generals" taking up position in the Hungarian infantry line!

The "generals" take up position behind a pavise and prepare to defend themselves with spear and crossbow!