Sunday, 30 September 2018

1513 Flodden Tudor English and a Reenacting update.



Perhaps not the most inspiring title for this post but over the Summer, while I had some time off work, I had a look at the army I can now muster for the English at Flodden. The beauty of this set up is that aside from the flags, which I specifically collected or printed out to represent some of the English Leaders at Flodden, most of the rest of the army is made up of figures that I already had for other projects. The white coated Bill and Bow and the Border Horse were painted for the English that campaigned in France in 1513. The unliveried archers are fairly generic and have been fielded as Frenchmen or "Rebels" in my games. Similarly most of the guns and some of the polearmed troops are also generic but really look the part here when fielded under the English Banners.

I have only included a few of the Banners and Standards that were carried at Flodden, many of the English Nobility and Gentry from the Northern Counties and the Royal Fleet took part. What I have done is included the Banners of the leaders of each of the English "Battles". So we have the Earl of Surrey and his two sons Thomas Howard, the Lord Admiral, and Edmund Howard who struggled in the opening stages of the clash ( my previous blog post covers this). In charge of the reserve is Lord Dacre and his Borderers while sir Edward Stanley takes the English left flank.

As many collectors of this period will know, although there are bits and pieces here and there for the Flodden Campaign, no manufacturer really covers it in depth and does it justice. Perhaps one day this will be rectified. Despite this I hope these pictures demonstrate that with a careful selection of figures and some conversion work a convincing Flodden English Army can be put together. The figures used here are of course plenty of the Perry's Late Medievals, some Wargames Foundry Wars of the Roses Infantry and Landsknechts, lots of converted Assault Group figures, some Steel Fist dismounted Men-at-Arms, Stuart's Tudor Dolls and a fairly large number of Old Citadel figures. I think there are nearly 70 of the Old Empire Archers from Citadel that were sculpted by the Perrys in the 1990s! The flags are a mix of Pete's Flags, Freezywater and even a few home print outs. I have Ray Rousell to thank for the home printed ones: https://onelover-ray.blogspot.com/search/label/Flodden%20flags.


An English Army of 1513

Edmund Howard, accompanied by Henry Gray and Christopher Savage.

Thomas Howard, Early of Surrey, whose men also fly Henry VIII's Dragon Standard, accompanied by Sir Marmaduke Constable and Lord Scrope.

Troops from Sir Edward Stanley.

The English Reserve under Lord Dacre

Dacre's Border Horse.

English Light Guns between the "Bill and Bow" Blocks.

Another picture of the Border Horse.

Surrey's Block with Thomas Howard, the Lord Admiral, and Edmund Howard in the distance.

The English centre under the Earl of Surrey.

An Early Tudor English Army for Flodden 1513.

The Border Horse form the reserve.

As the Summer is now over I thought you may like to see the developments in my Reenactment "Kit" for this year. I took part in an event every month from June through to September which is pretty good going for me. One of these was an event to commemorate Stoke Field at the Wargames Foundry which was a strange collision of both of my hobbies in one weekend, although they obviously overlap in many ways. While my wargaming collection is very much geared towards the 16th Century I indulge in my passion for the later 15th Century through my reenacting.

In terms of my armour the brigandine that I ordered last year has been completed by Ash of Armour Services Historical: https://www.armour-services-historical.co.uk/. It is based on the brigandine worn in Hans Memling's Beheading of John the Baptist and I think you will agree is a bloody good replica of the one worn in the painting! Over 400 rivets have been used in it to create the look seen below. It also has accompanying laced on "Spaulders" which are not worn in the original painting but were widely used in the period. The Pastrana Tapestries, depicting the Portugese King Alfono V's victories in North Africa and made in Flanders, contain many great representations of lots of brigandines with spaulders being worn, I have included a detail from this below.

Anyone that has painted the Perry Late Medieval Plastics will be interested to know that the the "studded" effect on the miniatures wearing brigandines is an attempt to try and represent the rivets seen here. One of the Light Cavalry Plastics even has the brigandine spaulders as well. It is a stunning piece of armour and I am very pleased with the final look it gives when worn with my maille and other pieces of armour. I am trying to create a look that could be straight from a Late 15th Century Illustration rather than looking like a "reenactor" and I feel I am getting closer to that goal with this.

Detail from St John Altarpiece, Hans Memling c.1479, showing the brigandine.

Detail from one of the Pastrana Tapestries woven in Tournai, late 15th Century. Note all the brigandine spaulders that are worn by the troops.

The finished replica.

My interpretation of a late 15th Century Infantryman.

In terms of my "civilian" style 15th Century "kit" I feel I have also moved closer to my goal of trying to look like someone who has stepped out of an art work or manuscript. Last year my "Mahoitred" doublet was completed. Mahoitres are the puffed shoulders which make you look like the incredible hulk, with a much bigger physique than you really have, when a coat or gown is worn over them! My doublet is based on the executioner's one in the Dieric Bouts Altar Piece, the detail of which is shown below. To complete the look I added a "Sleeveless Livery" or vest to this. I am not sure these garments really have an official name but they are basically a skirted vest that covers the points that fasten your doublet as well as your cod piece and backside. Those of us used to painting Landsknechts will be familiar with all sorts of scandalous attire but in the late 15th Century you were not considered fully dressed if simply wearing doublet and hose.

Of course there were all sorts of occasions when doublet and hose would be all that was worn, context is always key, but in terms of formal attire a coat or gown would normally be worn over the doublet, the doublet essentially being a foundation garment. If it was too warm to wear a full gown or coat, or perhaps the arms needed to be more free for movement, then a sleeveless version like this could be worn. Initially these items of clothing seem strange but when you take the time to have a look at the art of the period they appear all over the place. Many of you will note the similarity to the military style liveries worn over armour in the late 15th Century and the civilian ones are indeed very much the same. Whether or not the civilian ones were always in a Lord's colours like the military vests seems more open to question. There are lots of images of these, a few of which I have shown below, and it seems that while some may have been in a Lord's chosen colours in others they seem to just be another civilian garment. They may equally have been in the colours of a guild or fraternity rather than have been in the colours of a particular household, it's hard to say.

The finished look is shown in the last image below, I am sure next year I will want to tweak and change it again! As with my miniatures the reenacting is always a work in progress and the idea of ever completing an outfit doesn't really seem likely. Turning back to the miniatures I am currently working on yet another block of Landsknechts for the 1530s to 1550s this time. I am not sure I will have them ready by next month but they are on the way.

Barthélemy d’Eyck, 1450-60 Le Livre des Tournois. Note all the Sleeveless "Liveries" or "vests" worn by the men in the image.

Histoire de Renaud de Montauban, c.1470. Note the Sleeveless "Liveries" with a white edging.

A good view of one of these garments from the back, Histoire de Renaud de Montauban, c.1470.

A possible English Source for one of these garments, Literary Source from Morgan Library Museum England c.1470.

My doublet is based on this image, Justice of Emperor Otto III Beheading of the Inoccent Count and Ordeal by Fire Dieric Bouts c.1473-1475.

The finished look with a "Mahoitred Doublet" and "Sleeveless Livery".

16 comments:

  1. Wonderful looking army deployed, I did Flodden English in 15s decades ago and it's a fave! The lack of a specific range is odd, but your make do and mend approach worked wonders.

    I was interested in your reenactor kit, the end results look great. One thing that I love about the period is being able to link your figures to art works of the period. The biblical themes give great insights into period kit.

    BTW, what's with the beheading fetish?
    Cheers, Peter

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter - yes they did love a good depiction of a biblical beheading didn't they!

      Funnily enough I actually have a replica pewter plate similar to the one John the Baptist's head is being placed on!

      Delete
  2. Beautiful looking battle - figures and terrain superb. BUT, your kit is simply marvelous, Oli! Your brig fits perfectly and it looks amazing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Dean - the only problem with the Brig is I will really have to watch what I am eating for the start of every summer - otherwise there is no way I am fitting into that!

      Delete
  3. Wow great post Oli,great minis and terrian. But your reenactors kit steals the limelight,that brigandine is terrific and i love all the rest of your gear too, you really do look the period.
    Next time i am painting late 15th century medievals with a brigandine i will copy this!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Chris - I look forward to seeing you painted version of the brigandine, with forge blackarmour as well possibly?

      I have some good pics from the Stoke event and may put them up in another blog post.

      Delete
    2. Thanks Oli, would love to see photos of the stoke event.
      Hopefully steelfist will spoil us with plenty of wonderful figures of the period, then certainly paint one up as you, Forged black armour included!

      Delete
  4. The Flodden layout is marvelous, Oli.

    I shudder to think what the re-enator outfits cost, but the end result is very impressive indeed!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Peter. I know what you mean about the cost but I have been a reenactor for 23 years now and I did feel it was time to invest properly for another 20 years! It does make you realise how in the movies they can never get this stuff to look right - the time and money required for every single outfit is just not an option.

      Delete
  5. Lovely Flodden force,it's very tempting now that I've probably got enough figures for the Italian wars,its a great transitional period and I look forward to your Scottish force! Your kit looks awesome!
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Iain - the Scots are getting there - the only issue is you just need so many bloody pikes for a Scots Flodden army and in many ways it's a completely unique army for that one event.

      Delete
    2. I know exactly what you mean there !

      Delete
  6. I feel another Flodden themed game is due. Those look excellent Oli, a real sight to behold and you’ve done a great job in the photographs to depict them all.

    The kit is great and I can see how one must agonise over what to get. Yours is certainly very well researched and put together and it’s been a privilege to see it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Stuart, I agree that we haven't exhausted the Flodden options for games yet.

      With regards the kit - most of it would be fine for 1513 should the "Therouanne Tour" ever happen!

      Delete
    2. Most of the armour that is - definitely not the "civilian" stuff!

      Delete
    3. Well you just need a liveried base coat......

      Delete