Following on from my Cerignola refight I was keen to try another Italian Wars battle. So here we have Pieve di Cadore (also Pieve de Cadore or Cadore). I liked the idea of an Italian Wars battle in the snow and the fact I could use my landsknecht and Venetians. It didn't really go to plan for a couple of reasons. Firstly whilst I have chosen some photos for this write up about 90% of them were unusable. The white background just made the figures too dark and it didn't work at all. Secondly when I played through the game it went even better for the Venetians than the historical battle! A total rout of the Germans with them never clashing with the main body of Venetian infantry who were blocking their escape. As a result the write up of the actual game is fairly brief.
Pieve de Cadore, 1508
On 29th April 1507 the French king Louis XII entered Genoa in triumph having threatened it with a powerful army. With Louis also being the ruler of Milan the French were now dominant in northern Italy. This was not to the liking of Maximilian I, nominal ruler of the Hoy Roman Empire, who did not want the French closing in on yet another of his borders. In an Imperial diet at Constance Maximilian attempted to raise the funds to invade Italy, assert his Imperial rights and be crowned Emperor. The funds for 12,000 men were raised but Maximilian knew this was not enough to challenge the French.
Not wishing to pass up the opportunity of the money raised Maximilian changed his target from the French to the Venetians. He used the fact they had refused to ally with him against France as well as repeatedly refusing him passage through their territory as a pretext for a war which he hoped would expand the Habsburg territories. In February 1508 his troops began to invade Venetian territory. Despite the snow a diversionary force of around 4,000 German infantry under Paul Sixt I von Trautson invaded the Cadore region of the Dolomites. On hearing reports of this the Condottiere Captain Bartolomeo d'Alviano with a few hundred men at arms and light cavalry and a couple of thousand infantry under Pietro Monte moved over the mountain passes in an attempt to cut this force off.
On 2 March, as the Venetians drew near, the Germans attempted to retreat, adopting a formation with their baggage and camp followers in the centre of an infantry square. D'Alviano's light cavalry, consisting of mounted crossbowmen and stradiots, held up the Germans, allowing Pietro Monte's infantry to take up a position at a dry stream bed outside Pieve di Cadore and block the German retreat. Sixt von Trautson was slain, reputedly in a duel with Rinieri della Sassetta a Venetian standard bearer (although confusingly I have also read that he was beheaded shortly after the battle) and two thirds of his force failed to escape. A grateful Venetian republic richly rewarded d'Alviano, giving him some of the captured German artillery pieces. Maximilian's main force, heading for Verona, was blocked by d'Alviano's cousin, Niccolo Orsini da Pitigliano and the Habsburg ruler was forced into a humiliating retreat.
The game was played as always using adapted Renaissance Rampant rules and as in the last post the units deployed were fairly large to give the impression of a pitched battle. The aims of the two armies were simple with the Germans having to exit the table from the Venetian table edge and the Venetians having to stop as many of them as possible. All the wagons and camp followers behind the landsknecht were simply table dressing, representing the camp followers the army formed a square around to protect. They had no significance in the rules. The armies used were as follows:
Sixt von Trautson's Germans
1 Unit of Foot Knights (Sixt von Trautson)
4 Units of Landsknecht Pike
3 Units of Landsknecht Shot
2 Units of Landsknecht Halberdiers
Bartolomeo d'Alviano's Venetians
1 Unit of Men at Arms (Bartolomeo d'Alviano)
1 Unit of Men at Arms (Carlo Malatesta)
2 Units of Stradiots
1 Unit of Mounted Crossbowmen
1 Unit of Italian Pike (Pietro Monte)
1 Unit of Italian Pike
1 Unit of Italian Pike
2 Units of Italian Infantry
1 Unit of Italian Shot
1 Unit of Italian Crossbowmen
|A view of the Venetian infantry under Pietro Monte.|
|The Venetian right flank, comprised of mounted crossbowmen and stradiots.|
|The Venetian general, the condottiere captain Bartolomeo d'Alviano.|
|Sixt I von Trautson's Germans surround the baggage train. The force comprises pike, halberdiers and arquebusiers.|
|Von Trautson's force.|
|The German troops begin their attempt to break out of the Venetian blockade.|
As mentioned above this turned out to be a disaster for the Germans. Initially they had an early success, sending one of the stradiot units that came out to meet them fleeing after one volley of shot from a unit of landsknecht arquebusiers. This turned out to be the only Venetian unit they would destroy. As the rest of the Venetian light horse rode around the German left flank and Pietro Monte's arquebusiers and crossbowmen took up position in the frozen stream the oncoming German infantry suffered. Initially the German arquebusiers fired back at the Venetians but all of the German shot were soon routed leaving the rest of their infantry to face a steady rain of missiles from the Italian ranks.
The Germans were already disordered by the time they reached the frozen stream. There were brief clashes with the Italian crossbowmen and arquebusiers holding the steam. The Italians put up a heroic defence and although the crossbowmen were pushed back Von Trautson's men could not force a way across. Morale amongst them had fallen to such a level that when Von Trautson himself fell to the shot of an arquebusier the whole German force crumbled and began to melt away into the snow with the Venetian cavalry only too willing to chase them down.
|The opening stages of the battle. The Venetian arquebusiers and crossbowmen have moved into the dried (or possibly frozen) stream bed whilst their light cavalry begin to flank the Imperialist column.|
|A view from the baggage train as they trudge through the snow.|
|The front pike blocks prepare to engage. Von Trautson is just behind them under the white Habsburg banner in the foreground.|
|The German force comes under attack from the Venetian shot and crossbowmen.|
|For a moment it looks like battle will be joined all along the front. In the top left a block of pikemen can be seen heading towards the stradiots and mounted crossbowmen in an attempt to stop them harassing the column.|
|Close quarter fighting breaks out as the Germans reach the stream.|
|The Venetian arquebusiers put up an epic defence in the stream pouring shot into the advancing Germans and preventing them from crossing the ditch.|
|The Venetian crossbowmen also put up a heroic defence in the stream fighting off repeated attacks.|
|Von Trautson's forces have faltered and failed to cross the stream and even engage with the Pietro Monte's pike and swordsmen who are waiting for them.|
|Von Trautson is shot dead by the arquebusiers as he attempts to lead his men in the assault.|
|With their commander dead the German force crumbles and flees. The Venetian light horse are not far behind them.|
|A view from the panicked baggage train as the German army crumbles and flees.|
As you can see it turned out to be a very one sided engagement. I think most wargamers have had these games, often more times than they would care to remember! It was interesting to see the armies deployed in the snow terrain (also known as a white sheet on the table) and this could still be a interesting battle to refight. I think the German force would need some more missile units to give them more of a chance. Von Trautson had some artillery, as we know d'Alviano was awarded some of it after the battle, but I had imagined that would have been in the baggage train rather than being deployed for the engagement. Maybe a couple of light guns, and some better dice rolls, would have given them a greater chance at breaking out of the Venetian trap.
Table looks great, interesting scenario.ReplyDelete
Cheers Peter - it was interesting to try something different.Delete
Once again, a spectacular battle with gorgeous armies...Excellent!ReplyDelete
Thanks Phil, it was over pretty quickly but at least it looked different!Delete
That’s a great looking host! I love those pike blocks.ReplyDelete
Thank you, I agree there is nothing quite like the Landsknecht pike blocks.Delete
Looks great, and sometimes real battles are one sided as well!ReplyDelete
Battles on snow tend to look better in person, as all the white fools the camera and pictures do often come out dark.
Cheers Peter - yes the game did look better in the "flesh" so to speak. The white definitely changed the photos.Delete
I think the photos look great, great snow effects!ReplyDelete
Cheers Chris, actually this game reminded me of your Towton bases.Delete
Splendid models and interesting snowy terrain!ReplyDelete
I want to thank you because I new from Pietro del Monte Santa Maria biography that his pikemen won in Cadore a fight with Maximilian landsknechts by the stratagem of using pikes longer than the German ones. And now I know the episode :)
It is a pity that in this refight the pike block didn’t get to grips! Perhaps in the new one?
Thank you, if you can read Italian, which sadly I can't, there is a whole study on this battle: https://www.amazon.it/battaglia-Cadore-Giornata-internazionale-settembre/dp/8863020442Delete
With reference to Pietro Monte I do have a translation of his fight (and general advice) book - the "Collectanea". The author is thought to be the same Pietro Monte as the one in this battle, who died the following year at Agnadello. It is fascinating primary source on combat in the late 15th early 16th century and well worth a read.
Well, there are plenty of one sided battles and as you said this was a less than successful campaign for Maximilian who always seems to be searching down the back of the sofa for funding to field an army! Lovely figures, I quite like the white sheet,even if it's a little harsh!ReplyDelete
Cheers Iain - yes the white sheet was something different, worth a try. Maximilian's abortive campaigns provide all sorts of interesting scenarios for games - the 1490 Hunagarian invasion and more of his war with Venice are on the cards for future tabletop battles!Delete
Great set up Oli, I reckon a few snowy fir trees is all it needs. Nonetheless a great set up and focus on an interesting campaign.ReplyDelete
Cheers Stuart - yes I did think about some snowy terrain - that would have really looked the part for this game. Not sure how much use it would have normally though!Delete
As always your collections and AARs are excellent. I had never even heard of this battle in my reading. And yes, I agree, I have set up scenarios and then our local group fights them out and, sure enough, what I think is going to be a close one on occasion turns into a rout. Oh well.ReplyDelete
Thank you Joseph. It did end up being a total rout! As you will probably know from some of the Tudor scenarios I have done I love refighting the more obscure battles, raids, sieges and skirmishes from this era.Delete
Oli - fantastic set up and great write up.ReplyDelete
Cheer Stuart I am glad you enjoyed it, Italian Wars in the snow is something a bit different.Delete
Just sensational stuff- your figures are just so good! Great scenario too!ReplyDelete
Cheers John, the snow did help to make the Landsknecht units really stand out.Delete
A fine looking game. You can't go past massed pikes!ReplyDelete
It's a shame that you were not happy with most of your photos. Those that you have posted look great. Figures on snow terrain always look marvellous.
Cheers James, I think the white sheet seemed to suck some of the light in for some reason, may be the January light outside didnt help much either.Delete